KOSOVO: The Intervention "Pay-off" KOSOVO ( Theodor W. Fruendt for RNN ) February the 17th Ó Concept, photos and text by Theodor W. Fruendt
Ó
A region of Europe which has been given its freedom through the efforts of democratic governments and whose expelled population have been able to return to their homes, succeeded it's "ethnic cleansing"-operation with an mass exodus of almost the entire Roma-population in Kosovo.
Table of contents:
Much more photographs are available:
Foreword
The war is supposedly over, but Roma are leaving Kosovo under pressure by a self styled government under the leadership of KLA-general Hashim Thaci, his KLA and it's supporters.
Jiri Dienstbier, UNO representative for Human Rights in Kosovo, said in a report that "the UN is neither capable of establishing a civil government in Kosovo, nor can it guarantee protection for the non-Albanian minorities".
It is for the first time since the Holocaust, that European Roma minorities have been the victims of collective persecution. This people, who came to our continent for a thousand years ago suffered acts of brutality, rape, abduction and murder.
It is intolerable that a minority whose extermination Hitler set in motion should be experiencing collective persecution. Now we can see that many of the cowardly acts of murder recently committed in Kosovo remind us to the crimes of Milosevic's forces.
The following Report was done throughout a 5month period after arrival of NATO's Peaceforce K-FOR. I visited Kosovo, Macedonia, Bulgaria, Serbia and Montenegro.
In a region of Europe which has been given its freedom through the efforts of democratic governments and whose expelled population is able to return to their own homes, now the same Albanians are going back into their homes in Kosovo. But it is not so for Roma from Kosovo.
I wish to thank all the friends who helped me to realize this documentation:
Ali Latifi, Pristine
Anelore Hermes, Goettingen
Arber, the Hodsha
"Bureau Kolbow", entire team, Skopje
Dieter Klees, Skopje
Kurt Holl, ROM-ev. Cologne
Marina Achenbach, Berlin
Nikolaus von Holtey, Heidelberg
Natscha, Toni and Dejan, Skopje
Stefan Stefanovic, Skopje
Zoran Dimov, Skopje
And most of all, Hussein, Tahir, Fatmir, his wife Assemina and her two soons, Jusufa, and all other Romas in all camps in Macedonia, Kosovo, Serbia and Montenegro.
KOSOVO
All village-names are written in Serbo-Croatian language, to compare the dates given in this report with UNHCR-dates, which relay on the latest valid census 1991
Remaining Roma communities inside Kosovo, October 1999
There is a pre-war table available, but most important is the supply with aid and healthcare for those which are still remain and live under permanent threat:
Municipality: Decan = 129 (in 3 villages)
Municipality: Urosevac = 2423 (in 13 villages)
Municipality: Gnjilane = 34 (in 3 villages)
Municipality: Djakovica = 10920 (in 15 villages)
Municipality: Gracanica = 150
Municipality: Istok = 557 (in 19 villages)
Municipality: Kamenica = 295 (in 5 villages)
Municipality: Kosovo Polje = 2345 (in 7 villages)
Municipality: Lipjan = 172 (in 19 villages)
Municipality: Malisevo = 28 (just in Bela Crkva)
Municipality: Mitrovica = 691 (in 11 villages)
Municipality: Obilic = 135 (in 5 villages)
Municipality: Pec = 1105 (in 15 villages)
Municipality: Podujevo = 1039 (in 5 villages)
Municipality: Prishtina = 928 (in 11 districts)
Municipality: Prizren = 339 (in 6 villages)
Municipality: Orahovac = 430 (in 2 villages)
Municipality: Stimlje = 334 (in 3 villages)
Municipality: Strpci = 68 (in 3 villages)
Municipality: Vitina = 20
Municipality: Vucitrn = 72 (in 2 villages)
total: 22214
out off the prewar-level ~ 120.000
Ethnical Structures
The UNHCR-Fact-Sheet, August 1999, is giving a total number of 128.000 Rom in Kosovo. This are the most recent census data and they refer to the following ethnic groups living alongside the Albanian majority in Kosovo: Serbs and Montenegrins (10,75%), Bosniaks (3%), Turks (0,5%), Rom (2,5%), Croats (0,4%), "Yugoslavs" (0,15%).
People are described as Rom in Kosovo if their mother tongue is predominantly Romanes and when they have Serbian as their second language. But there is another group who speaks Albanian as their mother tongue. They claim themselves as "Ahskalias" and experts describe them as a sub-group. Still, they are ethnically Rom.
The majority of all those Rom in Kosovo professes the Muslim faith.
During the recent months of war (between the end of March 1998 and the beginning of June 1999) a considerable number of Rom fled from Serbian troops to places elsewhere in Kosovo or abroad. Abroad they mainly claimed themselves as "Albanians" when they were seeking for political asylum.
Reports of Roma being forced to co-operate with the Serbian military; Reports of Roma solidarity with Albanians
Execution by decapitation of a Roma man by the UCK. The UCK officer present at the "interrogation" said that the man was a butcher hired by the Serbs to cut up the bodies of dead Albanians. He had admitted everything. According to a UCK officer, "We have done to him what he did to the corpses - chopped off his head". (Additional information: it was Roma who were forced to bury the bodies of the victims of the Serbian massacre at Rahovec/ Orahovac in the summer of 1998. They were also the source of the information concerning the number of victims.) Die Welt, 26.06. 1999
In Ribar i Vogel and Rufc i Ri in the district of Lipjan/Ljipljane at least 40 Albanians were executed, including 4 or 5 women who were raped beforehand. This was reported to OSCE and the correspondent of the New York Times, David Rohde, by expulsees on 24 April. A witness named "Sali" reported that the day after this he saw fresh graves. Four of his uncles were buried in them. The paramilitaries had forced Roma to collect up the bodies and bury them. According to statements issued by the OSCE (Ron Redmond) there are several reports which are all in agreement concerning what happened.
The members of the mission were of the impression that only very few Roma willingly cooperated with the Serbian aggressors during the war. Many were pressurized or even coerced into working for the Serbian side. Several witnessed violent forms of pressure being applied. The Roma in Pristina for example were forced to take part in a pro-Milosevic demonstration. Others were recruited to serve as Yugoslav Army transport auxiliaries. Several were arrested in their homes and forcibly conscripted into paramilitary groups in the Pristina area. They were used as tools in the commission of atrocities against Albanians. OSCE/ ODIHR mission, 27 July to 6 August 1999
The spokesman for the Roma in the Fushe Kosova/ Kosovo Polje Roma refugee camp, J., acknowledged that some Roma had collaborated with Serbs. "All those involved withdrew along with the Serbian Army. But everyone who remained behind is innocent."
According to the vice-president of the World Union of Roma, Nikolic, "The leaders of the Roma in Kosovo have rendered their people very serious disservice." However many Roma were forced to work for the Serbian police or in the Yugoslavian Army. Nikolic estimated the number of the Roma in Kosovo at 100,000 to 150,000.
Ibrahim Makolli of the Albanian Council for the Defense of Human Rights and Freedoms CDHRF reported that during the war he arrived at a "checkpoint" manned by Roma and was threatened by them. He knew all the Roma. Makolli acknowledged that many Roma were forced to do what they did by Serbs. According to Makolli CDHRF also had proof that Roma had taken part in massacres. NYT, July 08. 1999
The Romany Union feared that the UCK intended to expel the entire Roma population of Kosovo. The UCK had tortured Roma to extract confessions of their collaboration from them. A UCK officer told the BBC that he estimated that most of the Roma had collaborated with the Serbs.
The Serbs and Roma remaining behind in Kosovo gathered together in enclaves or NATO safe havens to protect themselves. They were unwelcome as refugees in Belgrade and could not manage to find their way to a third country. This is how why Serbian ghettos in the northern part of Mitrovica or in the southern part of Prizren (in an orthodox seminary) came into being. In the latter case, 180 people - Serbs, alleged Albanian "traitors" and Roma - gathered around Father Nikola. Many of them had been forced to flee from their homes after which they were beaten and even tortured by members of the UCK. The 18-year-old M.B. reported that she had been raped by a group as revenge for her husband's alleged cooperation with the Belgrade regime. German soldiers guarded the Orthodox seminary. Father Nikola was one of 5 monks who stayed behind. According to Father Nikola there were up to 10,000 Serbs who used to live in Prizren and the surrounding area. Of these only 200 remain. Most of Serbian houses have been burned down and several people killed. Roma have also been the target of attacks under suspicion that they had allegedly collaborated with the Milosevic government. The alleged Albanian "traitors" are in the worst situation - they have nowhere else to go. According to Father Nikola no one dares to venture outside without an escort. It is too dangerous even for him to go to church. Many of the residents show evidence of mistreatment. A man by the name of Mustaf reported that he was unable to flee from his home village of Kijevo because of an injury. The Serbs had forced him to work for them. Then he was tortured by the UCK in Prizren. Likewise, X.B., who had returned from Germany, reported that he had been tortured by the UCK because he was falsely suspected of having spied for the Serbs. Many of those present had stood by and watched as their houses burned. Daily Telegraf July 22 1999
Statements of a Roma refugee from Kosovo in Belgrade: "The Kosovo Roma were loyal to the Serbian state. As a result they are now subjected to acts of revenge by the UCK." The President of the Roma Congress Party, Dragoljub Ackovic, stated that only 10,000 - 15,000 Roma remain in Kosovo, mostly the old and sick. In Fushe Kosova/ Kosovo Polje, where formerly approximately 6,000 Roma used to live, N.L. said that he was the last Roma left and he is now preparing to leave. Ackovic estimates that around 70-75 % of the Roma would prefer to come back. 15-20 % would like to remain in Serbia and the rest wish to go to a third country. In Serbia refugees from Kosovo have been classified as "internally displaced people", not refugees. This means that they receive no official humanitarian assistance and have no right to have their children educated or obtain employment. NYT, August 1999
UNHCR and OSCE:
September/October 1999
Kosovo Polje: previously 3,500 Roma, now 1,500-2,000
Podujevo: now 850 Roma
Obilic District (Krusevac, Plemetina, Obilic, Crkvena Vodica and Janina Voda): now 2,000 Roma (200 in Obilic).
Krusevac Roma camp: 1.200 Roma.
Plementina: 450-500 Roma remain, fewer than 10 families have fled.(K-FOR has a unit stationed here but the Roma still feel insecure. The setting of Roma houses on fire and the intimidation of Roma by Albanians are still continuing.)
Lipljan: 1,400 Roma remaining (170 driven out of Dobrotin and 120 from Medvece)
Magura: formerly 40 families, now 1 family
Vrelo: now 130 internally displaced persons
Mitrovica: In Leposavic and Zvecan Districts there are 500 internally displaced persons, who are being accepted by the Serbian authorities in increasingly limited numbers. They are being forced to make way for Kosovo Serbs returning from Serbia.
Vucitrn: 70 Kosovo Roma left out of a former 1,700
Gnjiljane: 445 individuals remaining
Bostane: 45 individuals remaining
Kamenica: approximately 100 Roma remaining
Vitina: approximately 300 out of 500 Roma remaining
Urosevac: approximately 3,500-4,000 Roma remaining
Stimlje: 200 Roma
Djurkovce: 200 Roma
According to UNHCR statements, 1,800 Gabeli Roma and Maxhupi Roma in Fushe Kosova/ Kosovo Polje, who have taken refuge in a school, have moved into a camp newly constructed by the British troops. The Roma were told that water and power would be cut off and the security forces protecting them from attacks would be withdrawn, so that the Roma were forced to agree to move to the vicinity of Obiliq/ Obilic. Approximately 300 m away from the camp is an Albanian village whose inhabitants have protested against the arrival of the Roma by throwing stones at the refugees. A refugee relief worker reported a serious threat on the part of the Albanian villagers to attack the refugee camp with hand grenades. According to the relief worker's report the Roma were living under constant fear of attack.
According to UNHCR statements, Roma and Serbs in Kosovo have been gathering together in enclaves under NATO protection in order to avoid reprisals by returning Albanians. Forgotten by Belgrade and in no position to make their way to a safe third country the Roma and Serbs have congregated in ghettos at a safer distance from their former Albanian neighbors. In Prizren 180 Roma and Serbs took shelter on the premises of an Orthodox seminary. They fled from their homes after they were beaten and tortured by Albanians, having been branded as collaborators.
OSCE/ODHIR
The members of the delegation were shocked at the atrocious conditions in several camps for internally displaced Roma, such as those in Obiliq/ Obilic and Gjakove/ Djakovica. It was clear to them that people could not continue living in conditions of this type and that refugee status in a third country was probably the only feasible alternative.
According to statements issued by UNHCR, it is becoming increasingly difficult to find accommodation in the Serbian heartland and in Montenegro for the Serbs and Roma refugees from Kosovo. In the area round Bujanovac in the southern part of Serbia 1,000 of 3,000 expulsees are already forced to live in tents, Judith Kumin, UNHCR spokesperson, said in Geneva on Tuesday, Aug. 08. 1999
Dennis McNamara, the UNHCR's Special Envoy for Kosovo, describes the position of the Roma who have fled from Kosovo to central Serbia as fundamentally desperate, and likewise that of the Serbs who fled from Kosovo. The consequences of the destruction of power stations by NATO bombing have made prospects for the winter even worse. Serbia's international isolation makes it particularly hard to find donors who will fund projects in Serbia.
August 06 1999
Figures given in the OSCE/ODIHR report on Roma refugees in the countries bordering Kosovo:
Serbia: 20,000 - 100,000
Macedonia: approximately 10,000
Montenegro: 5.000 - 8.000
Italy: several large groups (600 to 1.000)
Bosnia-Herzegovina: approximately 150 (according to UNHCR statements)
In an interview with German television ZDF, UNHCR spokesperson Judith Kumin said that the situation of the Serbs and Roma who had fled to southern Serbia was increasingly problematic. The refugees need to be provided with suitable facilities to cope with the winter which, given the difficult economic situation in Serbia, will be difficult without humanitarian assistance.
Article II (c) of the UN Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of Crimes of Genocide
Under the terms of Article II (c) of the UN Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of Crimes of Genocide of 9.12.1948 such mass deaths may form the basis for a charge of genocide against those Albanians responsible for the mass expulsion of the Roma.
This "ethnic cleansing" did not involve any campaign of genocide along the lines of the Serbian model but demonstrated instead that a mass exodus of population can be achieved simply through threats and intimidation and individual acts of brutality, rape, abduction and murder. The possibility that expulsion has resulted in deaths on a large scale in refugee camps in neighboring countries cannot be ignored
More photos please contact:
Failure of K-FOR to provide adequate protection
In Peja/ Pec the outlying districts of the city which were mainly inhabited by Serbs were set on fire. Those responsible first looted the houses and loaded up tractors. Cars were seen carrying registration plates from Kukes (Albania). K-FOR stood by and watched as the crimes took place without doing anything. The Italian forces had a particularly bad reputation. In the German sector K-FOR has set up an emergency telephone number. In Velika Hoca (Serbian name), where 3,000 Serbs used to live, the inhabitants are afraid of acts of aggression by returning Albanian expulsees and do not dare venture outside the village.
In Graca (500 inhabitants), 10 kilometers from Pristina, Albanian returnees expelled the Serbs and Roma. British K-FOR soldiers stood by without doing anything as homes went up in flames.
Along with his father and cousin, the 22-year-old F.G. was abducted from his home in Krusha e Madhe/ Velika Krusa by UCK fighters and so brutally mistreated that he was unable to make his way home. The ERRC attempted to inform K-FOR troops but were referred backwards and forwards between one post to another. It was only with difficulty that they were able to persuade K-FOR to come to the village and take the seriously injured F.G. to hospital. Members of ERRC had to go ahead of them on foot because of the danger of sniper action locally. (A K-FOR soldier said "I am not going to risk my life for you, you can be sure of that.") G. did not want to be taken to hospital unless he was given protection there. After having promised this, as soon as they were at the hospital K-FOR withdrew immediately.
The delegation reported that the Roma felt that generally they were not sufficiently protected by K-FOR. The K-FOR troops took too long in responding to threats to the Roma. The reason was that the K-FOR soldiers did not know enough about the situation of the in Kosovan society. The delegation found that K-FOR's willingness to protect the Roma increased as soon as they were provided with adequate and detailed information about the alarming position of the Roma.
OSCE/ODIHR mission, 27 July to 6 August 1999
The person in charge of the refugee camp in Krushevc/ Krusevac, near Obiliq/ Obilic, reported that when they informed K-FOR soldiers about incidents in the camp, the British soldiers simply replied "We don't understand". St Sava Youth Press Service, 21.8.1999
Municipalities of origin of Roma-"IDP’s" from Kosovo in Camp-Kornik-Podgorica-Montenegro
Names, ages and date of arrival on request
These are just Numbers of families:
From Decan: 38
From Djakovica: 672
From Glogovac: 5
From Gnjilane: 7
From Istok: 111
From Klina: 165
From Kosovo Mitrovica: 167
From Kosovo Polje: 293
From Lipljan: 242
From Obilic: 353
From Orahovac: 3
From Pec: 349
From Precale: 4
From Pristine: 182
From Srbica: 8
From Suva Reka: 38
From Vucitrn: 72
Out of this: Children and youth in the age: 0 - 17 = 1337
Justification
It is intolerable that a minority whose extermination Hitler set in motion - a people who dwelt on our continent for a thousand years ago - should be experiencing collective persecution.
It is for the second time since the Holocaust, that European Roma minorities have been the victims of collective persecution. Now we can see that many of the cowardly acts of murder recently committed in Kosovo remind us to the crimes of Milosevic's forces.
The "ethnic cleansing" did not involve any campaign along the lines of the Serbian model but demonstrated instead that a mass exodus of population can be achieved simply through threats and intimidation and individual acts of brutality, rape, abduction and murder.
The representatives of NATO, UN, USA and the European governments did not effectively condemned publicly the mass expulsion of entire Roma communities and the alarming racist behavior of a of the Kosovo Albanian population.
The continued economic assistance for Kosovo hasn't been made conditional on the Albanian population's in term of a correct treatment of the minorities. And, this despite the fact, that it is region of Europe, which has been given its freedom through the efforts of democratic governments and whose expelled population is able to return to their own homes.
K-FOR and the UN-police, UNIP, never maintained a day- and night presence in all Roma communities in order to protect the population under threat.
In the Italian, French, German and US sectors; KFOR needs to arrest troublemakers. While KFOR has been more effective in the British sector, there, too, it has failed to protect minorities.
The winter has been taken place all over the regions were refugees are living also in tents. I receive almost every day messages by refugees which are giving reports of bad conditions because of the cold, lack of food-supply, even their children are dying in hospitals, because once they finally coming to a hospital, it is often too late.
Camps, such like Stenkovac 2, Macedonia, are closed down only because of political reasons. It remains to be seen how the UNHCR-Program is going to fail. Once to the supply with humanitarian aid stops, the situation will detour into social problems not only for the refugee but also those private families who give them shelter.
As a heavy storm the Kornik-camp in Podgorica has blown 113 tents away, were in one night hundreds of refugees lost their tents, UNHCR was urging for help, after leaving the camp for many month under control of a local "refugee-profiteer" who is a Roma by himself.
Zagreb, February 2000
________________________________________________________________________________
Reports in Media’s
For further informations please contact:
Theodor W. Fruendt
Tel + Fax: +385 1 3760439
Email: